Should I kill the Crones in Witcher 3?

post-thumb

Should I kill the Crones Witcher?

The decision to kill the Crones in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is not an easy one. These characters, known as the Ladies of the Wood, play a significant role in the game’s story and have a complex relationship with the game’s protagonist, Geralt of Rivia.

Table Of Contents

On one hand, the Crones are portrayed as manipulative and cruel beings who have caused immense suffering to the people of Velen. They have made deals with villagers, demanding sacrifices and using their powers for their own twisted purposes. Many players may see killing them as a way to bring justice and liberation to the region.

On the other hand, the Crones are also portrayed as ancient and powerful beings with their own motivations and desires. Their actions, while brutal, are driven by a desire to survive and maintain their power. Some players may be intrigued by their mysterious nature and choose to spare them to learn more about their history and intentions.

Ultimately, the decision to kill or spare the Crones is up to the player and their own moral compass. The game presents both options with consequences, and the choices made can impact the game’s narrative and ending. So, should you kill the Crones? The answer lies within the depths of your own conscience.

The Controversy: Killing the Crones in Witcher 3 - Pros and Cons

The choice to kill the Crones in Witcher 3, also known as the Ladies of the Wood, is a highly debated topic among players. While some argue that killing the Crones is the right thing to do, others believe that sparing them is the more ethical choice. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of killing the Crones in Witcher 3.

Pros:

  1. Moral Justification: Killing the Crones can be seen as a moral act, as they are known for their malevolence and manipulation of innocent people. By eliminating them, Geralt, the protagonist, can restore peace to the region and protect the villagers from their wickedness.
  2. Quest Resolution: Killing the Crones can provide a sense of closure for players who have been following the main questline. It allows for the completion of the story arc associated with the Crones and their involvement in the narrative.
  3. Character Development: Killing the Crones allows Geralt to assert his agency and make a decisive action that reflects his values and principles. It can contribute to his character development and the sense of empowerment that players experience throughout the game.

Cons:

  1. Ethical Dilemma: Sparing the Crones raises an ethical dilemma for players. While they are undoubtedly twisted and evil, they also have significance in the story and the world of Witcher 3. Choosing not to kill them can be seen as a more morally complex and nuanced decision.
  2. Unforeseen Consequences: Killing the Crones may have unforeseen consequences, as their actions and presence in the world of Witcher 3 are intertwined with the narrative and the overall balance of power. The repercussions of their death may ripple throughout the game’s world, affecting other characters and storylines.
  3. Alternative Ending: By sparing the Crones, players can unlock an alternative ending that offers a different perspective on the story and its themes. Choosing not to kill them provides a more nuanced and non-binary resolution to the conflict.

In conclusion, the decision to kill the Crones in Witcher 3 is a complex and subjective one. It ultimately depends on the player’s personal values, moral compass, and desire for different narrative outcomes. Both choices have their pros and cons, and each can provide a unique and meaningful experience within the game.

The Story Behind the Crones

The Crones are three witch sisters who play a significant role in the world of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. These ancient, monstrous beings are often depicted as grotesque and sinister figures, with their hideous appearances reflecting their true natures.

The Crones are known by different names in different regions. In Velen, they are referred to as the Ladies of the Wood, while in other areas they are called the Whispering Hillock or the Orphans of Crookback Bog. Despite their various names, they are always described as being malevolent and powerful.

Legend has it that the Crones were originally three sisters who lived in a small village in Velen. As the story goes, they made a pact with a dark force, known as the Spirit of the Forest, in exchange for eternal life and power. However, this pact came at a terrible cost – the sisters were transformed into hideous hags, forever cursed to live in the swamps of Crookback Bog.

The Crones are not only physically repulsive, but their actions are equally abhorrent. They are depicted as cannibalistic creatures who feast on the bodies of those who come into their territory. They are also known for their manipulation and deception, often toying with the lives of humans for their own amusement.

Despite their evil nature, the Crones play a crucial role in the world of The Witcher, being intricately tied to several key quests in the game. Their knowledge of the surrounding area and their control over magical forces make them formidable adversaries for Geralt, the game’s protagonist. Players must decide whether to align with the Crones or oppose them, with their choices having significant consequences for the outcome of the game.

Pros of Killing the Crones

  1. Ending their reign of terror: The Crones, also known as the Ladies of the Wood, are notorious for their cruelty and evil deeds. Killing them would put an end to their reign of terror and protect the innocent villagers who live in fear of them.
  2. Saving the orphans: The Crones are responsible for the abduction and exploitation of young children. By eliminating them, you would be rescuing the helpless orphans and preventing further harm to them.
  3. Breaking their dark magic: The Crones possess powerful magic that they use to manipulate and control others. By killing them, you would be breaking their hold on the region and freeing the people from their malevolent influence.
  4. Collecting valuable rewards: Killing the Crones would not only bring justice but also offer valuable rewards. The villagers and other grateful individuals may offer you riches, rare items, and useful information as a token of their gratitude.
  5. Strengthening your reputation: Slaying the infamous Crones would enhance your reputation as a brave and heroic Witcher. Other people in the region would see you as a savior and seek your help, opening up new opportunities and quests.
  6. Preserving the natural balance: The Crones are connected to dark forces and engage in twisted rituals that disrupt the natural order. By eliminating them, you would be restoring balance to the land and protecting nature from their corrupting influence.
  7. Preventing future atrocities: The Crones have a history of committing gruesome acts and causing suffering wherever they go. Killing them would ensure that they are unable to continue their malevolent activities and prevent future atrocities from occurring.
  8. Gaining closure for the doomed village: The Crones have plagued a nearby village for generations, making the lives of the villagers miserable. Killing them would finally bring closure to the long-suffering residents and allow them to start rebuilding their lives in peace.

Cons of Killing the Crones

Killing the Crones in Witcher 3 may have some negative consequences for players who choose to take this path.

1. Missed Opportunities: By killing the Crones, players will miss out on certain quests and interactions related to them. These quests could provide valuable rewards, unique story elements, and insights into the game’s lore.

2. Faction Reactions: Killing the Crones may have negative effects on Geralt’s standing with certain factions in the game. It could lead to consequences, such as hostility or refusal of aid from characters associated with those factions. This could make certain parts of the game more challenging.

Read Also: Ways to Get Genesis Crystals in Genshin Impact Without Spending Money

3. Moral Dilemmas: The decision to kill the Crones raises moral questions. These characters, though sinister, have their own motivations and roles in the game’s world. Killing them may raise doubts about whether it was the right decision or if other paths could have been taken.

4. Story Impact: Killing the Crones could significantly alter the game’s story and ending. Players who choose this path might miss out on certain plot points, character development, or alternative storylines that could have been experienced by sparing the Crones.

5. Weakening the Balance: The Crones are powerful beings with their own place within the Witcher universe. Killing them could disrupt the balance of power and have unforeseen consequences for the game’s world and its inhabitants.

6. Uncertainty: Killing the Crones means never fully discovering their true nature, their secrets, or the extent of their influence in the game’s world. This uncertainty might leave players with unanswered questions and a sense of unfinished business.

Read Also: How to Find Your PS3 Model Number: A Quick Guide

Ultimately, the decision to kill the Crones or spare them depends on the player’s personal preferences, moral compass, and desire for exploration within the game’s narrative. It is a choice that carries its own set of pros and cons, adding depth and complexity to the Witcher 3 experience.

Impact on the Game: What Happens if You Kill the Crones?

If you choose to kill the Crones in Witcher 3, it will have a significant impact on the game and the outcome of certain quests. The Crones play a crucial role in the game’s main story arc and are central characters in several quests. Their fate and the decisions you make regarding them can greatly alter the story and its eventual outcome.

By killing the Crones, you eliminate a powerful group of beings who are known for their malevolence and cruelty. This can be seen as a righteous act, as they have committed numerous crimes and caused immense suffering to the people of Velen. The act of killing them, however, is not without consequences and can lead to unforeseen challenges and moral dilemmas.

One of the immediate consequences of killing the Crones is the breakdown of their hold on the village of Downwarren. With the Crones gone, the villagers are freed from their oppressive rule and can begin to rebuild their lives. This can be seen as a positive outcome, as the villagers no longer have to live in fear and can work towards a better future.

On the other hand, killing the Crones can also have negative consequences. The absence of the Crones can unleash chaos and uncertainty in the region. The power vacuum left by their demise may lead to various factions vying for control, causing instability and further suffering for the people of Velen. In addition, the consequences of your actions can influence the moral choices and alliances you make throughout the game.

It is important to note that killing the Crones is just one possible outcome in the game. The Witcher 3 offers players multiple choices and branching storylines, allowing for different paths and endings. Whether you decide to kill the Crones or spare them, the game will present you with different challenges and consequences that will shape your overall gaming experience.

The Immediate Consequences

Choosing to kill the Crones in Witcher 3 has immediate consequences that affect both the player and the game’s world. Once the Crones are dead, the Whispering Hillock spirit is released, which has a significant impact on Velen. The villagers of Downwarren are relieved from their suffering, and the area becomes free from the Crones’ control.

However, not everyone is happy with this outcome. The orphans of Crookback Bog lose their source of protection and guidance, leaving them vulnerable and abandoned. The death of the Crones also results in the disappearance and possible death of the Ladies of the Wood, who played a crucial role in protecting the region from evil forces.

Additionally, killing the Crones may lead to a strained relationship with the local population. Some villagers may view it as an act of violence and retaliation, making Geralt’s presence less welcome in the region. This can affect future interactions and quests in Velen, potentially leading to missed opportunities or hostile encounters.

On a personal level, the decision to kill the Crones weighs heavily on Geralt’s conscience. Choosing to end the lives of these powerful beings raises moral questions about the role of justice and revenge in the world of The Witcher. Geralt’s actions have a lasting impact on his character development, influencing his relationships with others and shaping his own sense of morality.

In conclusion, killing the Crones brings immediate relief to the villagers of Downwarren, but it also comes with consequences such as the abandonment of the orphans and strained relationships with the local population. It raises moral dilemmas for Geralt and affects his personal growth throughout the game.

Long-term Effects and Quest Outcomes

Deciding whether to kill the Crones in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt has long-term effects and significant consequences for the outcome of various quests in the game. The Crones, also known as the Ladies of the Wood, are powerful and malevolent beings who hold a significant role in the game’s main storyline.

If the player chooses to kill the Crones, it will have a profound impact on the surrounding characters and factions. Some characters, such as the orphans of Crookback Bog, might display gratitude, as they are free from the Crones’ oppressive rule. However, other characters, such as the villagers of Downwarren, might be furious and hostile towards Geralt, as they believe the Crones are the only ones keeping the evil of the swamp at bay.

The decision to kill the Crones also affects the outcome of the ladies’ questline. The player may choose to align with the Crones and aid them in fulfilling their twisted desires, or take a stand against them and attempt to bring justice to the region. Each choice leads to a different resolution and can alter the overall state of the game world.

Besides the immediate consequences, killing the Crones has far-reaching effects on the story and the fate of certain characters. For instance, sparing the Crones may result in freeing Anna and Tamara from their curse, whereas killing them removes any hope of saving the Baron’s family. It is essential to consider the potential consequences of one’s actions carefully.

Ultimately, the decision to kill the Crones in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a complex one with significant long-term effects and quest outcomes. It is up to the player to weigh the moral implications, consider the consequences for the characters and factions involved, and shape the fate of the game world accordingly.

FAQ:

Are there any consequences to killing the Crones in Witcher 3?

Yes, there are consequences to killing the Crones in Witcher 3. The outcome of the game’s main storyline will be affected, and you will miss out on certain quests and rewards that are available if you choose to spare them. Additionally, killing the Crones can have an impact on the overall tone and atmosphere of the game, as they play a significant role in the dark and twisted world of The Witcher.

What kind of quests and rewards will I miss out on if I kill the Crones?

If you choose to kill the Crones in Witcher 3, you will miss out on several side quests and valuable rewards. Some of these quests involve interacting with the Crones and uncovering more about their dark past. By killing them, you will not have the opportunity to explore these storylines and complete the associated quests. Additionally, the Crones drop unique items upon their defeat, which you will not obtain if you decide to spare them.

What are the benefits of killing the Crones in Witcher 3?

Killing the Crones in Witcher 3 has its own set of benefits. By eliminating these malevolent beings from the world, you are ensuring that innocent people will no longer fall victim to their dark rituals and schemes. It is also a way to seek justice for the suffering they have caused. Furthermore, some players may prefer a more morally righteous path, and killing the Crones aligns with their personal values.

Will killing the Crones affect my relationship with other characters in the game?

Yes, killing the Crones in Witcher 3 can have an impact on your relationships with other characters. The Crones are connected to various factions and individuals in the game, and your actions against them can be seen as either positive or negative by different characters. Some may appreciate your decision to rid the world of these evil entities, while others may view it as unnecessary violence. It is important to consider the potential consequences before making your choice.

Is there a non-violent way to deal with the Crones in Witcher 3?

No, there is no non-violent way to deal with the Crones in Witcher 3. The game does not provide you with a diplomatic option or alternative resolution for this particular conflict. If you wish to progress through the story and resolve the Crones’ storyline, you will need to engage in combat with them. However, it is worth noting that throughout the game, there are multiple situations where players are given choices that allow for non-violent resolutions.

Can I kill the Crones and still complete the main storyline in Witcher 3?

Yes, it is possible to kill the Crones and still complete the main storyline in Witcher 3. While killing the Crones will have consequences and impact the overall outcome of the game, it does not necessarily prevent you from reaching the end of the main storyline. However, it is important to note that your choices throughout the game can significantly change the narrative and lead to different endings, so it is advised to consider all possible outcomes before making your final decision.

See Also:

comments powered by Disqus

You May Also Like